BC has remained an unheralded local side for most of its existence having made just two single season appearances in the Amateurliga Rheinland (III) in 1972–73 and 1974–75.

Tied for 13th place with VfB Lützel and Eintracht Höhr-Grenzhausen at the end of the 1973 season Ahrweil lost a relegation play-off and was sent down.

The club became a founding member of the Verbandsliga Rheinland (IV) in 1978 and stayed in this league until 1986, a fourth place in 1981–82 being its best result.

The club played in the tier seven Bezirksliga Rheinland-Mitte until consecutively being relegated in 2013 and 2014 but recovered with a league championship in the Kreisliga B Ahr in 2015–16.

In their first season 2018/19 Ahrweiler BC ranked second place being qualified to the Qualification matches against FV Dudenhofen and SF Köllerbach.