[3] In July 2009, he left Deveau's and began training with Coach Gene Watson, first at Indy School of Gymnastics[4] and then at InterActive Academy in Zionsville, Indiana.

[2] He was part of the 2014 Pacific Rim Championships team in Richmond, British Columbia, Canada, where he won two gold medals, a silver and a bronze.

[2] He was also a part of the 2014 Junior Pan Am Championships in Aracaju, Brazil, where he won four gold medals and a silver.

[8] On August 19, 2014, Yoder won the bronze medal in the boys' individual all-around at the 2014 Youth Olympic Games in Nanjing, China.

[12] Yoder's full recovery from labrum and bicep surgery led him to being named back to the Senior National Team for 2017-18[13] after finishing 11th All-Around at the 2017 P&G Championships.

Yoder continued his elite career in February 2018 by again making the 2018 Senior National Team following his performance at the 2018 Winter Cup, where he claimed sixth place in the All-Around and an individual event championship in the pommel horse.

[24] Yoder then traveled to Japan again for Team USA in October 2021 for the FIG World Championships where he again made the pommel horse event finals, finishing fifth.

[28] On November 12, 2014, Yoder signed a National Letter of Intent accepting a full-ride gymnastics scholarship to compete for the Ohio State University starting in 2015–16.

His recovery was in time to compete in 2017 where he won four pommel horse event titles capped off by helping lead Ohio State to back-to-back Big Ten Team Championships,[32] a silver medal on parallel bars at Big Ten event finals,[33] and then a second-place team finish at NCAAs where he finished in sixth in the All-Around and fourth in pommel horse less than a year after surgery.

[34] At NCAAs in 2018, Yoder finished third in the All-Around, fourth in pommel horse, and seventh in parallel bars.