During his college years he also played for Ventura County Fusion in the USL Premier Development League, scoring the winning goal in the 2009 PDL Championship Game.
[5] Motagalvan played in 28 of the Rhinos' 30 USSF Division 2 matches, in addition to both playoff games.
On February 3, 2012, it was announced that Fort Lauderdale Strikers of the North American Soccer League had signed Motagalvan.
[3] While still an active player, he served as an assistant coach for Folsom Lake College's men's soccer program.
[3] Motagalvan was called up to the United States national beach soccer team in August 2014.