[1] On AllMusic, Stephen Thomas Erlewine said, "... Bobby Rush settles into a comfortable groove on All My Love for You....

This is a bright, largely cheerful affair, filled with punchy rhythms, tart horns, and clean licks.

Dialing back his signature raunch a notch, Rush sings with an audible grin throughout the record..."[2] In Blues Blast Magazine Ken Billett wrote, "These new songs provide insights into a man who loves telling a good story and has fun doing so, while emphasizing the groove – that Bobby Rush funky groove – audiences have adored for more than sixty years.... A true gift for today's blues fans, Rush has earned the right to be called an elder statesman of the genre that is the backbone of modern American music.

"[3] In Blues Rock Review, Meghan Roos said, "All My Love for You offers listeners a balance between the raw energy brought on 2020's Rawer than Raw and 2016's funk-infused Porcupine Meat, both of which snagged Rush's two Grammys for Best Traditional Blues Album.

Rush sings like he's deeply engaged with the emotions of the moment..."[4] All songs written by Emmett Ellis Jr.