[2][3] It was the group's last studio album before the Pips retired and Knight embarked on a solo career.

[6] Carole Bayer Sager and Burt Bacharach wrote and produced two tracks on the album.

[7] AllMusic wrote that "most of the time, All Our Love sounds fairly organic rather than forced or contrived ...

"[8] Robert Christgau thought that "Knight has one of those burgundy voices, designed to age, and since her albums have rarely done it justice, the edgy writing and overall strength of this multiproducer soul-dance-pop-whatever comeback is a gift.

"[11] The New York Times wrote: "Having landed on MCA, the venerable pop-soul vocal group has made an album that subtly updates its sound without tampering with a basic recipe in which the Pips' voices punctuate and curl around Gladys Knight's warm dusky alto.