At Christianity Today, Russ Breimeier rated the album five stars, stating she "score[s] a home run with most every track".

[3] Mike Rimmer of Cross Rhythms rated the album nine out of ten squares, writing that the release "finds her hitting her stride.

"[4] At CCM Magazine, Lizza Connor graded the album an A, highlighting that she is "still hitting repeat.

"[7] At New Release Tuesday, Kevin Davis rated the album five stars, affirming that he "highly recommend" because "She has an amazing singing voice and is easily the best female Christian songwriter.

"[6] However, Ashleigh Kittle of Allmusic rated it three stars, stating that "It provides listeners with a further glimpse into the heart of Groves, offering 13 new acoustic folk-pop and at time country-flavored songs focusing on a variety of relationships.