In 1883, the original building was moved to the current church site at College Avenue and Drew Street, adjacent to Lawrence University.

An estimated 1,500 to 2,000 people attended the cornerstone-laying service, presided over by Bishop Charles Chapman Grafton, on October 1, 1905.

The altar, which was fairly new, the reredos, the organ, the carved choir stalls, a Tiffany window, and the bishop's chair were destroyed, but the baptistry was spared.

The interior of the church dates from 1950, rebuilt after the fire by architectural firm Maurey Lee Allen.

[5][6] In 1959, building plans by J. Rouman & Associates for the parish center were approved,[2] and the rectory and neighboring house on the corner were torn down.

Gerald F. Gilmore, formerly assistant minister at St. John's Episcopal Church, Lafayette Square, became rector in 1949.

[9](See folder 4, Correspondence, Nathan Pusey Presidential Papers, 1925-2005 | Lawrence University Archives) All Saints is a worship community with activities including Sunday School, adult education, youth group, music ministry, pastoral care and a parish nursing program.

With its central, downtown location, the building is used by community groups including Attic Theatre, events for Lawrence University and meetings of the Diocese of Fond du Lac.