The parish continued to grow rapidly, and a new site was purchased at 132 North Euclid for the building of a 600-seat church.

It was designed by architects Roland Coate (1890–1958), Reginald Davis Johnson (1882–1952) and Gordon Kaufmann (1888–1949), and it is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

The architects for these buildings were Cyril Bennett and Fitch Harrison Haskell, designers of the Civic Auditorium.

[2] A series of long rectorships began with the arrival of the Reverend Leslie E. Learned in 1908: All Saints leaders and parishioners agreed that the church needed to add to its building space to house the increased scope of its activities.

In 2008, the commission ruled that the proposed project could not proceed until a new full environmental impact report (EIR) could be produced and approved.

[10] Although a casual look at the chronology listed below might suggest that All Saints began to be serious about social activism only in the mid-1960s, Rector George Regas clarified this point in a 1990 interview.

Regas compared Burt to a biblical prophet calling the faithful to be aware of their own shortcomings and urging them to get busy in their own house and communities to remedy these social ills.

[11] In September 2006, the IRS issued a summons against All Saints demanding that the church turn over documents related to the controversial sermon.

[20]According to the Pasadena Star News, the IRS told church officials that the sermon constituted an endorsement of a candidate.

The Church has also requested that the U.S. Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA) examine the IRS's investigation.

[22] In 2008, relations with the local Jewish community were strained when the Church hosted the pro-Palestinian Sabeel conference.