These deaths likely had a strong impact on the "intimate relationship" between father and daughters, as noted by a contemporary biographer.

Amalie Tischbein was considered an "outstanding beauty" or graceful, intelligent, and eloquent, and was frequently portrayed by her father.

[3][4] In Weimar, which she visited in 1775, Amalie Tischbein met the poet Christoph Martin Wieland, who dedicated an ode (Der Grazien jüngste zu schildern ...) to her in gratitude for a self-portrait she had produced [5] an expression of friendship not uncommon at the time.

[7] She lived "as a divorced woman [...] sufficiently provided for" in high esteem in Kassel society until her death.

The estates of the Fiorino and Bose families in Kassel are also said to have included works by her, but their whereabouts (as of 2016) remain unclear for the time being.