A year later, Eurobowl VI was added to the "Cru" trophy cabinet with a 42–21 win over Torino Giaguari (Italy) at Uppsala, Sweden.

The "Cru" returned to Dutch competition in 1996 and set about building up the club to include flag football, youth and senior teams.

In recent years Amsterdam Crusaders have dominated the American Football Bond Nederland competition, having won 8 of the last 9 national titles.

In 2006 they posted their first undefeated season in many years, but were made to fight for the ultimate crown by the Delft Dragons, who were only defeated in overtime - the only time this has occurred in the Tulip Bowl's history.

The Crusaders were given a tough draw and lost their group games 23–0 to 2005 finalists Templiers d'Elancourt and 38–14 to eventual semi-finalists Zurich Renegades.

In 2007, the Crusaders were handed a tough EFAF Cup draw, with an away trip to Oslo Vikings followed by a home matchup vs the German Football League's Berlin Adler.

On 13 July 2008 the Cru won the Tulip Bowl for the 14th time in their history after a 7–3 regular season, ensuring they enter their 25th year of existence as Dutch Champion.

Amsterdam hosted Danish champions Triangle Razorbacks on 20 April 2008 but slipped to a disappointing 3–0 loss to end their Euro season for 2008.

The Cru destroyed old foes Rotterdam Trojans 60–3 on 21 June in the AFBN playoffs and on 12 July dismissed Lightning Leiden 36–7 to win their 15th Tulip Bowl.

On 18 April 18 the Crusaders pulled off a remarkable come-from-behind victory in England against the Farnham Knights of Great Britain as QB Claudio Bartolozzi and WR Revilinho Graanoogst connected for a 7-yard score as time expired.

On 2 May 2009, the Cru sealed their first ever EFAF Cup semi-final spot by defeating the highly rated Oslo Vikings in Amsterdam by a score of 10–6.

Amsterdam's EFAF Cup season ended prematurely after a defeat in a visit to Les Cougars de St-Ouen l'Aumone (France) and a 35–7 home reverse versus British champions London Blitz.

The Crusaders were beaten for the first time in 28 domestic competitive games, losing 12–7 after narrowly failing to complete a 99-yard TD drive inside the two-minute warning.