Men's sports offered at Anderson University include football, basketball, baseball, lacrosse, tennis, golf, soccer, cross country, and track & field.

Women's sports offered at Anderson University include basketball, softball, lacrosse, tennis, volleyball, soccer, golf, cross country, and track & field.

Most athletic teams have on-campus facilities for competition, including Macholtz Stadium for football, and O. C. Lewis Gymnasium for basketball and women's volleyball.

[citation needed] In 2008, a new all-weather synthetic field turf and outdoor game lights were installed at Macholtz Stadium.

After graduating from Anderson College in 1973,[5] Donley returned to his alma mater in 1976 to serve two seasons as offensive coordinator.

[citation needed] Some notable accomplishments are: In more recent history, the women's basketball team made their first appearance in the Division III NCAA Tournament in 2000-2001.