It was speculated by the media that Gutman would sign a homegrown contract with the Chicago Fire once again, but he returned to Indiana for his senior season.
[6][7][8] He was listed as a first-team All-American by United Soccer Coaches,[9] and won the men's TopDrawerSoccer.com National Player of the Year Award.
[14] Following the 2018 NCAA Division I men's soccer season, Gutman was offered a one-week trial with Scottish Premiership side Rangers starting on December 18.
[24] On June 15, 2019, Gutman helped Charlotte to a 4–1 victory over Birmingham Legion, scoring the opening goal of the match.
[25] On August 3, 2019, Gutman was loaned to Major League Soccer side FC Cincinnati through the 2020 MLS season.
[27] On August 10, 2019, Gutman made his Major League Soccer debut for Cincinnati, appearing as a starter in a 2–2 draw with Columbus Crew.
[29] On March 9, 2021, Gutman was signed permanently by Major League Soccer club Atlanta United on a three-year deal from Celtic.
[30] On March 9, 2021, Gutman was signed by Atlanta United and then immediately loaned to the New York Red Bulls for the 2021 season.
[30] On April 17, 2021, Gutman made his debut for New York, appearing as a starter in a 2–1 loss to Sporting Kansas City.