Andrew J. Cusick (December 1857 – August 6, 1929) was an Irish-born catcher in Major League Baseball from 1884 to 1887.

He started his professional baseball career in 1883 with the Interstate League's Wilmington Quicksteps.

The Sporting Life reported that "[Cusick] comes to Milwaukee highly recommended by Fogarty, Wood and Mulvey, of the Philadelphias, who say he is a good batsman, a No.

[5] According to the Sporting Life that month, "[Cusick] umpired the Omaha series, and gave fair satisfaction.

"[6] After he umpired a game in June, the Milwaukee Journal reported that he "gave some very doubtful decisions on both sides and was especially incorrect on calling balls and strikes and of course brought down the anathemas of the vigorous-lunged 'bleachers' upon himself in consequence.