The song was released in November 2011 as the band's first single without group member Brian Bandas, and the first from their self-titled album.

"[2] Taste of Country writer Billy Dukes gave the song three stars out of five, saying that its story has "been told thousand of times before" but that it is "still really difficult to resist".

"[4] Directed by Chris Hicky, the video features the duo falling for two different girls: Eric picks up a brunette-haired woman wearing a leather jacket and a pair of jeans (who carries a flask with her) at a stable on his motorcycle.

Stephen picks up a blonde-haired woman wearing a white long coat and scarf with a skirt at her house in his Ford Mustang.

The video ends with the duo taking their respective dates to the same church and revealing that the women are possibly sisters as well as Preacher's daughters.