In 2006, while serving as chief of police in Long Beach, Batts became embroiled in "lobstergate": three officers reported colleagues for fishing for lobsters while on duty.

[11] During his tenure in Baltimore, his team implemented reforms that led to dramatic reductions in all metrics used to assess police performance, including declines in all Part I crime statistics, excessive force complaints, and citizen grievances.

[15] Reports also cited the controversial handling of the Freddie Gray case as a factor leading to his removal.

[17] Batts has received numerous awards and commendations for heroism, crime reduction, community activism, and innovative programs.

Batts was also honored by the Anti-Defamation League for his community outreach efforts to combat antisemitism, bigotry, and other forms of intolerance.

Batts's former wife is Laura Richardson, a Californian Democrat and former member of the United States House of Representatives.