The Eagles disbanded in the mid-1950s and the park subsequently became the home for the local American Legion Post 45 team and the Asheboro High School Blue Comets.

In the spring of 2010, McCrary Park received some significant upgrades, including the installation of a state-of-the-art synthetic infield surface.

The Copperheads first started participating in the Coastal Plain League during the 1999 season[3] and in 2000 reached the CPL championship series but lost to Petersburg.

Keith Ritsche, an assistant coach at Winston-Salem State University, an NCAA Division II institution that plays in the CIAA, became the team's field manager just prior to the 2014 season and held that position 2016.

McCrary Park has also been the site of the American Legion Southeast Regional baseball tournament in early August since 2013 and is scheduled to host the event at least through 2020.