They are currently members of the Midland League Premier Division and play at Sheepy Road.

[3] Following World War II, they were league champions in 1947–48,[3] also winning the Birmingham Senior Cup.

When the Combination folded in 1954, all but one of the clubs joined the Birmingham & District League, with Atherstone placed in the transitional Northern Division.

The club was immediately reformed as Atherstone United, taking the reserve team's place in Division One of the West Midlands (Regional) League.

[4] Another FA Cup first round appearance the following season saw them hold Fourth Division Hereford United to a 0–0 draw at Sheepy Road, before losing the replay at Edgar Street 3–0.

The club was then reformed under the name Atherstone Town, joining Division One of the Midland Combination for the 2004–05 season.