They also qualified for the playoffs, and earned at least 90 (with no less than 92 to be exact) points in the standings during each of their four seasons Atlantic City.

[1] Their biggest rivals were the in-state Trenton Titans, whom they met three times in the postseason (with every series between the two teams ending in a sweep, as the Boardwalk Bullies would win the first two, while the Titans emerged victorious during the third and final playoff matchup), while annually competing for the Garden State Cup, which would be awarded to whatever team in between the two that won the regular season series.

Former Boardwalk Bullies, and Titans head coach Mike Haviland would also coach the victor of the three playoff matchups between the two clubs, while also never losing a postseason game in the process all three times the Boardwalk Bullies & Titans competed against each-other during postseason play.

The attendance would also drop to an all time low, slightly below an average of 2500 in their fourth, and final season.

Before the 2015–16 season the franchise relocated again to Glens Falls, New York to play as the Adirondack Thunder.