[1] The Seagulls began as an independent amateur team in 1930, playing exhibition games in their inaugural season.
After formalizing the organization the following year, the team became a founding member of the Tri-State Hockey League.
[2] Atlantic City was a staple of the EAHL for nine seasons but the team began experience problems due to World War II.
Due to financial and personnel constraints, the team posted its worst performance in 1942.
After the war, a second Atlantic City Seagulls team was founded, although it had no connection to this franchise.