They found a force of Guelphs awaiting them at the fields of Pieve al Toppo, in Tuscany.

After the Battle of Pieve al Toppo, the victors burnt the town of Civitella in Val di Chiana, wrecking or damaging all of the buildings.

In the years in the wake of the battle, the city-state of Florence swept off the Arezzo territories in the Province of Siena, and took over the city in 1289.

Arezzo found itself at war with Florence, and the city fell after a short battle in 1311.

Pieve al Toppo remained in the hands of Arezzo until 1348, when it became the seat of a Florentine podesta.