Opened in 1991, the mall features Dunham's Sports, Marshalls, Ollie's Bargain Outlet, and PetSmart, with vacancies previously occupied by Younkers, JCPenney, and Target.

[12] These new owners have planned a $200,000 renovation of the mall property, including a new sign on Wilder Road.

[17] The movie theater complex was expanded in 2014, adding two new auditoriums with stadium seating for a total of ten screens.

[19] Target announced one month later that its store at Bay City Mall would close in 2015.

[23] On August 18, 2018, it was announced a farming supply store called Big R (now known as Stock + Field) would be replacing the former Target.

[25] Dunham's Sports, which operated a store in the Target wing, moved to the former Younkers Furniture location in September 2019.