Of the ten original members, only Seymour, and West De Pere have remained in the conference since its inception.

Hortonville cited travel times and costs as well as the imbalance that existed in the Bay Conference as reasons to leave.

[5] In December 2013, the WIAA Board of Control gave first approval for the departure of Denmark, Luxemburg–Casco, Marinette and Oconto Falls to the Eastern Valley in Return for the FRCC's Green Bay East & West and the EVC's Xavier.

A final vote was taken after the 40-day appeal window & successfully passed for implementation for the 2015–2016 school year along with several other conference realignments.

However, in September 2016, West De Pere requested to move to the FRCC, citing inadequate athletic competition in the Bay and a school size that was rapidly growing.

In December 2019, as part of the realignment process, West De Pere formally filed a request to move to the FRCC.

FVL will return in 2024 and teams in the Bay and Northeastern will have 1 Crossover game to count in the conference and playoff standings.