During her career she posted a .569 batting average and .638 OBP with 31 home runs, 18 triples, 41 doubles and 144 RBI.

During her first year in conference play she led the team in home runs (5), RBI (16) and slugging (.493), ranked second in batting average (.280) and third in on-base percentage (.325).

[12][13] During her senior year in 2022, she led the conference in batting average (.434), slugging percentage (1.007), home runs (24), RBI (71) and total bases (149).

[14] Her 24 home runs were the second most in a single-season in program history, trailing Kristen Rivera's record of 25.

[15][16] She was also named a top-three finalist for the USA Softball Collegiate Player of the Year.

[18][19] In January 2025, Klinger joined the Sultanes de Monterrey of the Mexican Softball League.

[22] She also represented the United States at the 2017 Junior Women's Softball World Championship.

[24] On August 31, 2023, Klingler was named to the United States women's national softball team for the 2023 Pan American Games.