[1][2] Adam, a high school English teacher devastated by the tragic deaths of his wife and son in an auto accident, turns to alcohol to numb his overwhelming guilt and despair.

Eager for a chance to apologize to his son's spirit, Adam arrives at the island only to find himself in a decaying boarding house run by Anthony, an 82-year-old recluse who is himself haunted by the ghost of his lover from sixty years prior.

[4][5] Critics and readers have praised Beautiful, Frightening, and Silent for its lyrical prose, complex character development, and its ability to evoke a strong emotional response.

[8] Reedsy's review by Kassie Romo points out the dark, twisted, and lyrical nature of the book, emphasizing the emotional journey it takes the reader on through themes of grief and guilt.

The reviewer notes the book's balance between the real world and paranormal elements, praising Gordon's poetic and flowery writing style, despite acknowledging it might not suit all readers' preferences.