The song was written by Chris Tompkins, Mark Holman, and Travis Wood, while Joey Moi produced the track.

[1][2] It was released to country radio stations in Canada and Australia, and is the third single from Porter's 2024 album Nobody's Born with a Broken Heart.

Taking that risk is both the most exciting and scary feeling, and I love that this song is able to put words to the back and forth you have in your head throughout those types of relationships".

[5] Meghan Grisham of Circle All Access favourably reviewed "Bet You Break My Heart", describing it as "a catchy tune that dives deep into the ups and downs of a relationship".

She added that the song "captures the realness of love and the pain that often comes with it", noting "relatable lyrics" and a "soulful vibe".