In 1919, a team known as Bethesda Comrades[2] were playing in the North Wales Coast League.

A long Welsh Cup run in 1960 saw wins over Nantlle Vale, Penmaenmawr and Pwllheli which set up a Quarter Final date with Cardiff City which ended in a six nil defeat against the eventual winners.

In 1976 they beat Oswestry Town but were knocked out by Bangor City at Farrar Road.

The score was 4–2 goals from Broadhead, Olney and John Hughes for Bangor and Alan Leicester for Bethesda.

In 1974 Bethesda knocked out South Liverpool in the Qualifying rounds of The FA Cup but were eventually beaten by Rhyl in a second replay after two drawn matches.

[3] Two players, Gareth Davies and Richie Owen, scored 70 goals between them over the course of the season.

In August 2012 they were not able to complete fixtures and were given 14 days by the league's Management Committee to resolve their issues.

[7] The club announced in September that it was disbanding and resigned from the league "due to various circumstances".