[1] The current Cemaes Bay Football Club was not formed until 1976 and joined the Anglesey League for the 1976–77 season.

[1] In the 1991–92 season Cemaes Bay won the Cookson Cup, beating Llangefni Town 1–0.

[1] At the end of 1997 the club's main financial backer resigned and they also lost several key players.

They regularly challenged at the top of the table for the next four seasons, but in 2004–05 were relegated to the Welsh Alliance and in 2005–06 dropped to the Gwynedd League.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.