[6][7] AllMusic reviewed Billboard Heart, stating "Throughout, Dobson's passionate, punk-inflected vocals, flaws-and-all instrumental takes, and an actively-burning-out vibe sell songs that are anxious even in affectionate moments.

"[3] New Noise Magazine gave the album a 3-star rating and remarked "Billboard Heart is like a self-help book contextualized in music.

"[9] Ben Jardine of Under the Radar described it as having the "trademarked sense of weightlessness" as the band's previous albums, stating "it’s also earmarked by crunchier guitars, soaring synths, and the occasional heavy drum fill.

"[1] Paste magazine wrote a review about Billboard Heart, stating it is "full of snappy lyrics, impeccable guitar-playing and crisp synthwork in a tight clasp, and the result is indie rock that sounds like it was made with both the confidence of a 22-year-old bursting onto the scene and the wisdom of a veteran player.

"[2] Clash magazine commented about the album, "it sees the group at the top of their game delivering an ambitious, eclectic eleven tracks that really showcase Jessica Dobson and co’s songwriting and musicianship.