[24] They finished the season out with victories against the Montreal Victorias, Trois-Rivières, McGill University, Ottawa Stewartons, and Winnipeg All-Stars.
[40] Prior to the start of the season, Foote left the team to join an automobile ambulance corps and Sortwell was unable to play due to outside commitments.
[41] Hamlyn Robbins, Paul Smart, Stephen Hopkins, Dettmar Jones, and Jack Hutchinson began playing for the B.A.A this year.
Huntington also secured the services of some former high school players, including Cliff Peabody, Don Sands, Milton Stearns, and Sammy Wendell.
[50] The Boston Athletic Association and St. Nicholas Hockey Club both finished the AAHL season with 6–2 records and played a three-game playoff series to determine the champion.
After the Harvard Club folded, George A. Percy, Gus Doty, Jack Wylde, and Alec Bright signed with the B.A.A.
Before the season began, Tuck was named head coach of the Dartmouth Big Green men's ice hockey and was replaced as captain by Percy.
[75][76][77] On February 17, the Boston A.A. defeated the Shoe Trades 5 to 3 in double overtime to win both the Winsor Cup and the group one championship.
The final game was played under protest, as the Shoe Trade's leading scorer, George Dufresne, was declared ineligible by the league.
[78] The Unicorn played the Cleveland Athletic Club in a four-game playoff, with the winner facing Eveleth for the league championship.
They defeated La Tuque and Queen's College and lost to the Winnipeg Hockey Club and the Toronto Aura Lee (the latter team beating the B.A.A.
added Ned Bigelow, Justin McCarthy, Harry Snelling, Bobby Emmons, and Carl Stillman to play alongside returning players Percy, Hutchinson, Ingalls, Rice, Bright, Stubbs, Doty, and LaCroix.
[89] They started the 1921–22 season with two exhibition games against Harvard University and a contest against the Sudbury Wolves, all of which were won by the Boston Athletic Association.
this year were Eddie Enright, Gerry Geran, Irving Small, Willard Rice, John Lyons, and Alphonse Lacroix.
[109][110][111][112] On April 14, 1923, the Boston Athletic Association hockey players were presented with gold watches at a banquet held at the club.
[113] On October 29, 1923, the members of the United States Amateur Hockey Association voted to build the 1924 U.S. Olympic squad around the champion B.A.A.
[115] He, Small, Geran, Enright, Campbell, Smith, Lyons, Rice, and LaCroix returned while Jim Healey (Victorias), Hago Harrington (Melrose High School), Len Morrissey (Boston College), Hugh Nickle (MIT), and Tubber Cronin (Cambridge High and Latin School) joined this year.
[119] The Unicorn started its season on December 8, 1923, with a 2–0 win over Boston's newest USAHA team – the Maple Athletic Association.
The two teams remained deadlocked after four overtime periods and under USAHA rules, the game was supposed to continue until a winner was decided.
[124][125][126] When the series moved to Pittsburgh for Game 4, Tubber Cronin was unable to join the team, as his studies at Boston College prevented him from traveling.
[128][129] In November, The Boston Globe reported that Princeton star Howell Van Gerbig would replace Tubber Cronin, who had joined the B.C.
[130] During a January 17 game at the Duquesne Gardens, Fort Pitt Hornet Joe Sills struck Boston Athletic Association defenseman Leo Hughes in the eyes with his stick.
[131] On January 20, B.A.A vice president George W. Wightman issued the following statement regarding Hughes' injury: "The governing committee of the Boston Athletic Association...deplores the rough tactics which it believes members of the Pittsburg team were permitted to employ in that game.
in the interest of clean sport, will withdraw its team from further league competition and will forthwith resign its membership in the United States Amateur Hockey Association.
Van Gerbig was eventually convinced by his mother to sit out the remainder of the regular season, however he returned for the Eastern championship series against the Hornets.
[135][136] Irving Small was knocked unconscious in a game against Berlin when defenseman Bill Sharpe hit him across the face with his stick in retaliation for hooking.
William F. Garcelon was named league president, George Owen Sr. was chosen to serve as secretary–treasurer, and Ralph Hornblower, Rudolph von Bernuth, and Alfred Winsor were elected to the board of governors.
team included George Owen Jr., Jack Hutchinson, Johnny Martin, Buck Dumaine, Art Langley, Bub Eaton, and Clark Hodder.
The Unicorn defeated St. Nicholas 2–0 and Pere Marquette beat the New York Athletic Club 7–1 in a doubleheader at the Boston Arena.
[148] On December 27, the Unicorn traveled to Madison Square Garden, where they beat the New York A.C. 5–2 before a crowd of 6,000 in a doubleheader that also featured the Knickerbockers and St.