He started 31 consecutive games at right tackle, the longest streak at the University of Virginia since 1998.

Butler drew attention in 2005 when he hit Boston College defensive end Mathias Kiwanuka with a chop-block in the back of his knees several seconds after the whistle, in what is referred to as "the cheap shot heard 'round the ACC.

"[1] Butler was suspended for the following game by his own team as a result of the dirty late hit.

In 2009, Butler was voted to USA Today's All-Joe Team which honors hardworking and valuable players who are overlooked.

He retired from professional football after the 2009 season, stating, "My passion for education, country and community is something that I am ready to devote my full attention to.