[6] In 2019, her sophomore season, she was named First-Team All-American by United Soccer Coaches along with teammates Alessia Russo and Emily Fox, and helped the Tar Heels reach the 2019 College Cup Final.

[1] In the 2020 season (extended into Spring 2021 because of the COVID-19 pandemic), Pinto helped North Carolina reach the semifinal of the NCAA Tournament, where she scored a goal in the Tar Heels' 1–3 loss to Santa Clara.

[8] She was named First-Team All America for the second straight year[9] and one of the three women's finalists for Hermann Trophy, given to the best collegiate soccer player of the season by the Missouri Athletic Club.

[10] In January 2021, Pinto announced she was entering the 2021 NWSL Draft, although she planned to finish her junior season at North Carolina, with the 2020 NCAA Division I Women's Soccer Tournament moved to Spring 2021 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

[15] The Courage had lost Kerolin at the end of the 2023 season with a torn ACL and head coach Sean Nahas moved her to the No.

[17] Pinto received her first senior national team callup in January 2017, and at age 16, she was the youngest player named to the United States' squad for the 2017 SheBelieves Cup, although she did not make an appearance in the tournament.

[19] In October 2020, Pinto, along with four other young athletes who called themselves Next Gen United, ran for and won seats on United States Soccer Federation's 20-person Athlete's Council, with the stated aim of diversifying the federation's leadership in age and culture.