The Clinton Bulldogs, Cushing Refiners, Drumright Boosters, Duncan Oilers, El Reno Railroaders, Guthrie Linters and Shawnee Indians joined the Producers in league play.
[1][2][3] The Bristow Producers ended the 1923 Oklahoma State League season with a record of 66–56 to place third in the overall standings under managers James Payne and Ralph Heatley.
In the playoff, the Bristow Producers swept the Duncan Oilers in four games to win the Oklahoma State League championship.
The final overall regular season standings were led by Duncan Oilers (71–53), Clinton Bulldogs (63–60), Cushing Refiners (67–53), Guthrie (57–64), El Reno Railroaders (56–63), Shawnee Indians (54–60) and Drumright Boosters/Ponca City Poncans (46–71).
Bristow was followed by the Cushing Refiners (49–27), Shawnee Indians (40–37), Duncan Oilers (33–37), Ponca City Poncans (32–44), Blackwell Gassers (20–53) and Guthrie/McAlester/Wewoka-Holdenville/Enid (18–48).