Formed in 1854, the Excelsior ballclub featured stars such as Jim Creighton, Asa Brainard, and Candy Cummings.

[4][5] They also were one of the first baseball clubs to undertake a long-distance tour to compete outside their home region.

In 1860, the Excelsior club made a now-famous tour around New York and large cities in surrounding states.

[6] In 1860 the Excelsiors compiled a record of 19 wins and two losses, and were champions of the National Association, finishing in a draw with the Brooklyn Atlantics Club.

During the 1860 season, the Excelsiors began wearing an ancestor of the modern, snug-fitting baseball cap, including a long visor and button top.