The Cadillac "Chiefs" became charter members of the reformed four–team Class D level Western Michigan League.
[1] The Chiefs joined the Holland Wooden Shoes, Muskegon Speed Boys and Traverse City Resorters in beginning league play on May 28, 1910.
[7] The Manistee Colts and Boyne City Boosters franchises joined the four returning 1910 teams in beginning league play on May 23, 1911.
[9] Playing under returning manager Calvin Wenger and Thomas Railing, Cadillac finished 47.5 games behind the first place and champion Manistee Champs in the six–team league final standings.
[6] Continuing Michigan State League play, the 1913 Cadillac Chiefs placed fifth in the final standings.
[15][6] The Cadillac Chiefs hosted minor league teams home games at Recreation Park.
Today, the Northern District Fair Grounds are located at 1320 North Mitchell Street, Cadillac, Michigan.