This left the practising school—now Calabar All-Age on Sutton Street—and the theological college, which was relocated at Studley Park (on Slipe Pen Road) in 1904.

Ernest Price and David Davies — Principal and Tutor, respectively, of Calabar Theological College, founded Calabar High School under the joint sponsorship of the Baptist Missionary Society of London and the Jamaica Baptist Union.

The high school opened 12 September 1912, with 26 boys; the foundation was laid in the Christian tradition.

An early benefactor was Elizabeth Purscell, who in 1919 bequeathed the adjoining property on Studley Park Road in trust for the school.

The school offered boarding facilities on nearby premises —the Hostel— to facilitate boys attending from outside the Corporate Area of Kingston.

In 1952, Calabar Theological College and Calabar High School moved from their location at Studley Park to Red Hills Road, where 60 acres (240,000 m2) of land (then called "Industry Pen") had been purchased for the re-siting of both institutions.

At the time, this was a thinly populated, undeveloped area and many people thought the move unwise.

When the school was relocated to Red Hills Road in 1953, the boys helped to construct the new pool.

The team was coached by old boys Sheldon Phillips and Romeo Monteith, with Nesta Dawkins as manager.

Ernst Price, medical missionary, Leprosy specialist, orthopaedic surgeon and discoverer of Podoconiosis