[4] Among its dishes are meatballs, eggplant parmigiana, roasted red snapper, roasted swordfish, dover sole, veal chops, ossobuco with saffron risotto, bomboloni, and cannoli.

[1] The restaurant exhibits two paintings and a sculpture by pop artist Donald Baechler.

[1][5][6] It also exhibits art by Frank Stella and Ellsworth Kelly, and four original Henri Matisse stencil lithographs.

[10] In 2013, a review in The New York Times described it as "one of the most civilized Italian restaurants to turn up anywhere in the city in the last few years," but also stated, "...for all its civility, [Caravaggio] is haunted by inconsistency more than three years into its run.

Some of my meals there were very good; in others, I couldn’t find a single dish to get excited about, and there were a few that were just not right at all."