After one season in the CSL, and finishing in the bottom half of the International Division the team ceased operations.

Notable alumni were Chris Handsor, Elvis Thomas, Bayete Smith, Anton Skerritt, Cameron Walker, St. Lucian internationals Éric Fanis and Edwin Ferdinand.

In their debut season in the CISL the club reached the playoffs semifinals, but were defeated by Toronto Italia.

[2][3] Following the demise of the Puma League the club was renamed the Caribbean Stars Community Promotions.

On March 16, 2006, the Caribbean Stars along with former Brampton Stallions manager Neil Palmer announced plans to field a team in the Canadian Soccer League for the 2006 season.