She won four medals at the 2019 Parapan American Games and was named one of Canada's flag bearers for the Closing Ceremony.

[1] Shibley competed in para-cycling at the 2019 Parapan American Games with pilot Meghan Lemiski.

[2] Shibley and Lemiski won the 2021 Canada Paracycling National Championship in women's tandem.

[4] In 2023, Shibley and pilot Meghan Brown, placed tenth in the para road cycling world championships.

[5] She won bronze, with Brown, in the women's tandem at the 2024 Para Cycling World Cup in Adelaide.