[10] Jaye directed and produced the 2010 American documentary film Daddy I Do which examines sex education and sexual abstinence programs in America.

[11] Daddy I Do included interviews with the founder of the Silver Ring Thing Denny Pattyn, feminist writer Amanda Marcotte, and Douglas Kirby.

The film also discusses personal stories from women facing teenage pregnancy, single motherhood, abortion and sexual assault.

[11][12] Bust magazine praised "Jaye for exposing the truth about abstinence-only programs, the stories of teenagers who buy into it, and its consequences".

[26][27][28] At the end of the film, Jaye states that she no longer identifies as a feminist,[29] saying that she now believes that "feminism is not the road to gender equality".

It focused particularly on how the process initially affirmed her feminist sense of otherism and outrage against the men's rights movement, but then later broke it down.

[31] Jaye's effort for the Kickstarter project was strongly criticized by some feminists[32] including David Futrelle, who runs a website called We Hunted the Mammoth and who said it looked like propaganda.

[23][25] It has also been criticized by Alan Scherstuhl of The Village Voice, among others, for failing to challenge controversial comments and behavior from men's rights figures such as Elam.

[30] In a 2017 interview with Australian TV show The Project, when Carrie Bickmore asked her about a recent high-profile murder of Luke Batty by his father, Jaye emphasized that it was a specific example of a male victim of domestic abuse, where Waleed Aly tersely rebuts, "that's the lesson you took from that?"

[29][43] After receiving a wave of comments critical of the hosts and supporting Jaye, Sunrise removed the video of the interview from their Facebook page.

Jaye also posted screenshots of emails to prove that Sunrise's producer had received a copy of the film a month before the interview and plenty of time for the hosts to have watched it.