According to the Southern Poverty Law Center, Catholic Family News is classified as a hate group for their adherence to integralism and the alleged antisemitism and other conspiracy theories.

[citation needed] Former Disney actor Murray Rundus joined CFN as Production Manager in 2023.

Catholic Family News has a close relationship with Marcel Lefebvre's Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX).

In April 2019, McCall was one of nineteen original signatories to an "open letter" accusing Pope Francis of heresy.

Articles have appeared on Sister Annella Zervas, O.S.B.,[6] Blessed Theodore Romzha, Mother Agnes Hart,[7] and Father Leo Heinrichs, O.F.M.