The team's success was capped at the 2009 Ontario Scotties Tournament of Hearts, where they finished the round robin with a 5-4 record.

At the end of the 2008/2009 curling season, Auld left the Goring team to form a new squad, taking longtime teammate Cheryl McPherson along with her.

For the fourth consecutive year, Auld would make the playoffs, but once again lost the 3-4 game, this time to Jacqueline Harrison.

After the 2009/2010 season, McPherson left the team, and returned to play with Alison Goring, a move that Auld would not recover from.

[3] Auld's team started well at the event, winning five out of six games, but lost three straight, one loss too many to qualify playoffs.