[1] Reiter attended IMG in Bradenton, Florida, for his senior year of high school.
[1] In 2007 Reiter also played two seasons with the Bradenton Academics in the USL Premier Development League.
[4][1] In 2009 in college he was ranked sixth nationally in points per game (1.78), eighth in goals per game (0.67) and 29th in assists per game (0.44) He was also voted Southern Conference Player of the Year by the league's coaches, First-team on National Soccer Coaches Association of America (NSCAA) All-South Region team, All-Southern Conference team and North Carolina Collegiate Sports Information Association (NCCSIA) All-State team, and named a CoSIDA/ESPN the Magazine First-Team Academic All-American and a NSCAA/Adidas First-Team Scholar All-American.
[5] During his junior year, he was a member of the US men's squad for the 2009 Maccabiah Games in Israel.
[4] Reiter made his professional debut on April 17, 2010, in a league match against Harrisburg City Islanders.