[2][3] In 2019, Sharp began attending Western Michigan University, where he played for the men's soccer team.
[11][12][13] He began his senior season with a hat trick in an exhibition match against the Cleveland State Vikings.
[34][35] On November 16, he scored a hat trick in a 3–0 victory over the Green Bay Phoenix.
[47] In 2023, he played with AFC Ann Arbor, where he was the team's leading goal scorer.
[49][50] After attending pre-season with the first team,[51] in February 2024, he signed a professional contract with Toronto FC II in MLS Next Pro.
[59][60] In September 2024, he signed a MLS contract with the Toronto FC first team through the 2025 season, with options for 2026 and 2027.