[4][5] The band's second studio album, Time to Go Home, was released on March 24, 2015, on Hardly Art.
[9] The album received significant praise from NPR's Mike Katzif, who wrote, "I Used To Spend So Much Time Alone is a thoughtful, reflective album, constantly searching for direction to and questioning every solitary, restless feeling, yet it's that intimacy that allows us to know a new, perhaps truer side to the artists.
"[10] After a brief hiatus in 2018, the group announced on July 10, 2019, that its fourth LP would be self-titled as Chastity Belt, and would be released on September 20.
[11] Writing for The Fader, Alex Robert Ross called it "the indie four-piece's lushest and most mournful-sounding album yet.
"[13] The group went on a tour as direct support for the rock musician Kurt Vile in 2021.