[2] Butler joined Los Angeles Temptation of the Lingerie Football League for the 2011–12 LFL season, playing as a wide receiver and defensive end.
[1][3] She captained the New South Wales Surge, Western Conference squad for the 2012 LFL All-Fantasy Game Tour.
[10][11] Butler was part of the first ever women's Bledisloe Cup double header before the All Blacks vs the Wallabies in 2016.
[19] In October 2017 Butler moved to England to play for south west London club Richmond FC in the Tyrrrell's Women's Rugby Championship.
[20][21] Butler dated Penrith Panthers and South Sydney Rabbitohs player Tim Grant.