She won the 1995 provincial championship playing third for Alison Goring's rink from the Bayview Country Club in Thornhill, Ontario.
This qualified the team to represent Ontario at the 1995 Scott Tournament of Hearts in Calgary, Canada's national women's curling championship.
McCrady would be on the Ontario team in two more Tournament of Hearts' as the alternate player.
McCrady would later join the Merklinger team as a normal player, throwing third stones.
She won her first World Curling Tour event at the 2010 Royal LePage OVCA Women's Fall Classic, defeating Tracy Horgan's rink in the final.