[3] O'Brien believed that the album would be perfect for getting the listener into the festive spirit, while the "many fun and happy songs" would be good for getting someone through the shopping, entertaining and family get-togethers.

[4] Puppini told a reporter for NPR Music that "O Holy Night" is a song that "she holds close to her heart", calling it "amazingly crafted.

[4] William Ruhlmann from AllMusic awarded the album three and a half stars out of five and branded it "an eclectic collection touching on their neo-swing tendencies.

"[1] A reporter for The Boston Globe gave the album a positive review, saying "It's fitting that a trio so indebted to the Andrews Sisters would include a cover of 'Mele Kalikimaka', the Hawaiian-themed Christmas song made famous by the Andrewses and Bing Crosby, on their new holiday release.

He thought the group excelled at singing the traditional Christmas carols, while the modern tracks lacked the fun of the originals.