She played less for her school the following two seasons, because of the COVID-19 pandemic and her club and national team duties, and posted twelve goals and nine assists in eight appearances.

[3][5] Hutton joined the Bethlehem varsity boys' team as a junior in 2022, starting at forward and contributing four goals and one assist in 14 games.

[7][8] After graduating one year early from high school in June 2023, Hutton trained with NWSL teams North Carolina Courage and NJ/NY Gotham FC.

[4][7] She considered her options for several months and eventually trained out with the Kansas City Current, which signed her to a three-year deal under the NWSL's Under-18 Entry Mechanism on December 14, 2023.

[15] Hutton played the fourth-most minutes for the Current (despite being away for a month at the 2024 FIFA U-20 Women's World Cup) as the team finished the regular season in fourth place.