The team plays its home matches at Historic Crew Stadium on the Ohio fairgrounds.
The club has had three managers in its history – Mark Wise, Daniel Seiffert, and Matt Ogden – and is 15-28-9 in six seasons in the WPSL.
Ogden is the head women's soccer coach at Capital University and won an Ohio Athletic Conference title with the Crusaders in 2015.
The crest was designed in-house by former Eagles midfielder Larissa Najjar (Ohio University) and received much public praise, making it to MLS Reddit and UniWatch.
In 2016 at MAPFRE, Eagles forward Molly Cornwell scored twice in the final 10 minutes of the match to beat Cincinnati Sirens FC, 2-1.
In 2017, the Eagles and Sirens played again at MAPFRE and Columbus won 4-2 on the back of two goals from Gunderson, one from defender Corie Moore, and one from forward Erin Brockway.
2018: Gogolin, Minnix, and captain Amber Kern (University of Akron) were named WPSL All-Conference players in 2018 after leading the Eagles to a record season.
Eagles fans voted goalkeeper Hannah Sargent (Western Michigan University) as the club's "Player of the Year" for her performance throughout the season.
In 2018, the WPSL named the Eagles the "Social Media Team of the Year" for its marketing efforts across Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube.
That match was played in front of a record crowd of more than 400 people at Columbus's home field at Otterbein University.