Company of Thieves were an American indie rock band from Chicago, Illinois, founded by Genevieve Schatz (vocals) and Marc Walloch (guitar).

They performed "Pressure", "Even in the Dark", "Past the Sleep" and "Around the Block" from their debut album, along with Hall & Oates songs "Starting All Over Again" and "Everytime You Go Away", as well as other covers.

They began as a trio with founding members Genevieve Schatz and Marc Walloch alongside drummer Mike Ortiz.

In 2011 Ortiz posted a formal letter to his fans on the official website of Company of Thieves stating his decision to depart from the band.

Faller played drums for the band's live performances after Mike Ortiz left along with bassist Marcin Sulewski.

On their 2012 tour, Company of Thieves appeared with Chris Faller as bassist on stage along with a new drummer, Matt Rullo.